2026
- Katelyn Williams, Shenandoah University D3
- Ruby Mills, Roanoke College D3
- Jamie Gatti, University of Mount Olive D2
- Henley Crandall, UVA - Wise D2
- Kensey Foster, Susquehanna University D3
2025
- Anna Carpinelli, Gardner-Webb University D1
- Chloe Holt, Longwood University D1
- Lakelyn Bostian, VCU D1
- Liv Tuebo, Kennesaw State D1
- Bevyn Nunnally, Meredith College D3
- Sydney Eldredge, Randolph-Macon D3
- Harlow Coker, Lenoir-Rhyne University D2
- Cana Brungard, Messiah University D3
- Olivia Mingee, Meredith College D3
- Takoda MacDougall, University of Colorado Pueblo D2
- Charlize Wolf, Western Connecticut State D3
- Avarie Mattlia, Stetson University D1
- Peyton Radford, Lynchburg D3
- Noelle Lacharite, Ferrum College D2
- Kaiah Cardani, Catawba College D2
2024
- Adleigh Huckstep, West Virginia Wesleyan D2
- Grace Virginia Deal, Catawba College D2
2023
- Abigayle Zaudtke, Bridgwater College D3
- Alexis Hilstrom, UVA Wise D2
- Maisen Jenkins, Bridgewater College D3
- Samantha Flippo, High Point University D1
- Whittaker Smith, Embry-Riddle D2